面向运动控制的5G与EtherCAT融合组网方案设计及其性能评估

Design and performance evaluation of 5G-EtherCAT integrated network for motion control

  • 摘要: 为应对开放自动化与云化控制趋势,本文探索了5G与EtherCAT融合的云化运动控制系统架构. 针对云化可编程逻辑控制器(Programmable logic controller, PLC)与现场设备在5G网络下的连接难题,提出一种基于虚拟扩展局域网(Virtual eXtensible local area network, VxLAN)的融合组网方案,通过网络虚拟化技术实现EtherCAT数据的透明传输. 其次,鉴于5G与专用工业协议存在显著性能差异,本文通过量化分析方法揭示了网络时延抖动影响运动控制稳定性的内在机理,建立了系统稳定运行周期与关键网络性能指标间的数学约束模型. 最后,在真实5G网络环境下搭建了实验平台,通过与有线网络对比测试,验证了所提融合架构的通用性与约束模型的有效性. 本研究不仅为传统工控系统的云化改造提供了可行的实施方案,更重要的是,提出了针对无线网络承载工控任务稳定性的分析方法与评估手段.

     

    Abstract: The advent of Industry 4.0 is leading to a radical restructuring of industrial control architectures, transitioning from the rigid, hierarchical models defined by the ISA-95 pyramid toward agile, decentralized cloud–edge–terminal architectures. Leveraging high bandwidth and low latency, 5G technology is poised to function as the critical enabler of this evolution, facilitating the migration of industrial controllers, such as programmable logic controllers (PLCs), from the factory floor to cloud or edge servers to support large-scale, collaborative control via wireless networks. However, establishing direct controller-to-device (C2D) links over 5G for high-precision applications, such as motion control, faces two fundamental challenges. The first is protocol incompatibility: high-performance standards like Ethernet for Control Automation Technology (EtherCAT) operate at Layer 2 of the OSI model using custom Ethernet frames, rendering them strictly incompatible with standard, IP-based (Layer 3) 5G routing. The second, and more profound challenge, is a fundamental performance mismatch. While EtherCAT necessitates deterministic, microsecond-level synchronization via mechanisms such as distributed clocks (DCs), 5G networks remain subject to inherent latency jitter stemming from radio channel fluctuations, interference, and resource scheduling. This non-deterministic jitter compromises the sensitive timing of EtherCAT, potentially leading to synchronization loss, control-loop instability, and system failure. To overcome these limitations, this study proposes a comprehensive strategy for integrating 5G and EtherCAT within cloud-based motion control systems, offering a two-fold contribution: (1) to resolve protocol disparities, we design and implement an integration architecture based on the Virtual eXtensible Local Area Network (VxLAN). By employing network virtualization to construct a Layer 2 overlay atop the 5G IP underlay, this mechanism encapsulates entire EtherCAT frames within standard User Datagram Protocol (UDP) packets; this ensures transparent transmission across the infrastructure, effectively rendering the 5G network a virtual ethernet segment from the perspective of the control system; (2) Concurrently, to address the stability challenges posed by jitter, we introduce a novel quantitative performance evaluation framework. Recognizing that establishing connectivity is distinct from ensuring operational stability, this framework analyzes the impact of network jitter on EtherCAT’s periodic data exchange. Subsequently, we derive a mathematical constraint model that explicitly correlates the minimum stable control period with key network performance indicators. This model serves as a robust predictive tool, allowing engineers to assess the feasibility of motion-control applications before physical deployment. The efficacy of both the VxLAN-based integration architecture and the analytical model is validated through extensive experimentation on a physical testbed using a commercial 5G network. By benchmarking the system performance, we demonstrate the solution’s practical feasibility and confirm the accuracy of the constraint model's predictions. Finally, this research extends beyond a functional integration scheme to provide a theoretic methodology for assessing the viability of deterministic, real-time industrial applications over non-deterministic wireless channels. Leveraging the proposed 5G-based motion control performance analytical methodology, this work seeks to promote the future deployment of 5G and its evolutions such as 5G-Advanced and 6G, in the most demanding sectors of industrial automation.

     

/

返回文章
返回